Pedestrian Level Wind Comfort

One of the important issues that need to be emphasized in terms of wind in building physics; If the height of the structure increases, the pressure zones grow. This basically means winds that accelerate in height around the structure. Designers need to consider the wind-related comfort situation, whether it be a high-rise building or a mixed project of many different buildings. Building owners make rental or sales plans in all commercial outdoor areas with the expectation of a comfort that is suitable for “long-term seated use”. In the initial design stage, Alkazar supports designers by working quickly on mass-based forms with comfort valuation in order to avoid such problems. Alkazar supported a number of projects for wind distribution around the building, where improvements in the current situation could be achieved by examining the wind directions. These are deciding what the position and shape of a windbreaker will be in the rooftop restaurant area, or interpreting the comfort experience of wind with humidity and temperature. By determining the shade hours that will occur due to the density of the buildings, the level that the wind velocity will reach with the building form is interpreted by combining it. In the analyzes that will be carried out for the improvements in the use of landscaping in projects with mixed structures, the types of trees and the pressure losses provided by them are modeled and the change of wind comfort is visualized. Pedestrian Level Wind Comfort
How the wind distribution will affect our comfort can be analyzed using historical climate data
Different criteria are used to make sense of wind comfort. In digital tests (CFD models) carried out by computational methods, visuals can be taken from any point or area. Thus, it can be calculated how even a change with a thin awning will change the comfort of the pedestrian level. The Beaufort scale describes the effect of wind speed on the physical comfort of the human body. For example, you don’t want the napkins on your table to fly for a quiet dinner. In this case, the wind velocity should not exceed 2.2 m/s.

Turning this into a step-by-step worked example: (1) the target activity class is defined: here, long-term sitting (an outdoor dining area); (2) the comfort threshold for that class is set: 2.2 m/s in this example; (3) using the area’s long-term wind statistics together with the CFD results modelled with the surrounding buildings, the percentage of time the wind speed exceeds this threshold (the exceedance frequency) is calculated; (4) if the exceedance frequency comes out high, mitigation options such as the position and height of a wind breaker are tested in the same model. The result is a numerical answer to “how often will your napkins fly off this table.”

In order for the design to meet this detail, the first point of our team is the analysis of the historical climate data of the region. Thus, both the determination of prevailing wind directions and the level of speed in the building region will be defined. Then, it is calculated how the project building, modeled together with the surrounding buildings, direct the wind. Pedestrian Level Wind Comfort What we have described above, should be needed for larger structures such as bridges or stadiums. For example, if the sound of the spectators who come to watch the match is not echoed in the stadium cause of prevailing winds, the morale will deteriorate. If we add to this situation the football team, which lost its advantage against the opponent due to the prevailing wind, the tension will increase. Of course, this may be acceptable for some due to the habits or cultural background of the spectators, but if the score of the match changes due to this, even the reconstruction of the stadium may be possible. In some bridges, the increase in the blowing speed of the side winds is so high that it poses a serious risk to small vehicles. Adjusting the height, position and permeability of the wind breakers to be made to the sides of the bridge can be tested digitally quickly. Alkazar team will calculate and visualize all the comfort you need for the wind at the first stage with you.

Activity classes

Comfort is assessed against the activity classes of Lawson-type criteria. Numerical speed thresholds are assessed per project against local long-term wind statistics; the table below shows the typical location for each class:

Activity classTypical location
Long-term sittingCafés, terraces, outdoor dining areas
Short-term sittingTemporary seating areas
StandingBuilding entrances, bus stops, waiting areas
StrollingWalkways, plazas, shopping streets
WalkingMain pedestrian routes, transit corridors

Lawson and NEN 8100: how the comfort criteria differ

TopicLawson (LDDC)NEN 8100
Origin and useOriginated in the United Kingdom; widely used on international projectsA Dutch standard; frequently cited across Europe
ClassificationActivity categories: long-term sitting, short-term sitting, standing, strolling, walkingComfort classes from A to E; the acceptable class is set by activity
Threshold logicA wind speed threshold and a permitted exceedance frequency for each activityThe percentage of the year a wind speed threshold is exceeded sets the class
SafetyWind speeds at danger level are checked separatelyWind danger (safety) is assessed separately
Numerical thresholdsTaken from the relevant standard text and stated with their source in the report. Which criterion applies depends on the project specification and certification target.

Sources: Lawson (LDDC) criteria; NEN 8100:2006.

When is it mandatory, and when is it recommended? The obligation depends on the regulation, specification and certification target the project falls under; for high-rise buildings within a regulation’s scope, whether pedestrian comfort is requested in the review process should be confirmed from the relevant text at the start of the project. It is recommended for shopping centres, campuses and mixed-use projects for operational comfort.

For practical examples: wind in passages under buildings and how courtyard openings affect pedestrian wind.

When is this needed?

  • High-rise buildings or mixed-use projects made up of several buildings
  • Leasing/sales plans for commercial outdoor areas expected to support long-term seated use
  • Wind-sensitive amenity spaces such as rooftop restaurants, terraces or mall entrances
  • Large-span structures such as stadiums and bridges

Process and deliverables

StepsDeliverables
Analysis of the area’s historical climate data (prevailing directions and intensity) → CFD simulation modelled together with surrounding buildings → comparison of wind speed at each point against its activity-class threshold → calculation of exceedance frequency from long-term statistics → testing mitigation options (wind breakers, canopies, planting) where neededComfort maps by activity class; threshold exceedance frequency results; safety-level check; comparison of mitigation scenarios

Let us discuss your project

A short first call to agree scope, timeline and deliverables. The same team that does the work answers.

Write to us by email Request a call

Reference projects

Get a quote: Share your massing model; let’s scope the pedestrian-level wind comfort study together. Contact us.

Pedestrian wind comfort: what is assessed and how

Short answer: Alkazar assesses wind speeds at pedestrian level with CFD simulation and reports comfort as exceedance of Lawson-type activity thresholds (sitting, standing, strolling, walking), plus a safety check. Mitigation options can be tested before construction. See also wind & CFD consultancy and facade wind loading.

Frequently asked questions

What is pedestrian level wind comfort?
It is the assessment of wind speeds at about 1.5–2 m above ground (where people actually walk, sit and queue) around and between buildings. Tall or closely spaced buildings accelerate wind down to street level, which can make entrances, terraces and open spaces unusable even when the building itself is structurally safe.
Which criteria are used to judge comfort?
Activity-based categories of the Lawson-type criteria: long-term sitting (cafés, terraces), short-term sitting, standing (entrances, bus stops), strolling and walking. For each location the wind speed is compared against the threshold for its intended activity and the exceedance frequency is calculated from long-term local wind statistics; a separate check covers safety-level gusts.
At which design stage should it be done?
As early as possible. At massing stage the geometry can still be changed, which is the cheapest way to fix a wind problem. Later stages are still useful for testing mitigation (canopies, screens, wind breakers, planting and parapet changes) before construction.
Can mitigation options be tested?
Yes. Alkazar has tested the position and shape of wind breakers for rooftop restaurants and open areas, and evaluated comfort together with temperature and humidity when the outdoor experience, not just the wind speed, is what matters.
What input produces the comfort map?
It is produced by combining the area’s long-term local wind statistics with the CFD velocity field modelled together with the surrounding buildings; each point is compared against the threshold for its intended activity to calculate the exceedance frequency.
Is a wind tunnel test required for pedestrian wind comfort?
There is no single rule; the regulation, specification or authority decides which method is accepted. CFD is a widely used method for pedestrian comfort studies. If a tunnel test is requested on your project, we recommend confirming it from the specification at the start.
Wind tunnel or CFD for pedestrian comfort?
A tunnel test is needed if the specification asks for it. If not, and the aim is to assess the velocity field around and between buildings, threshold exceedance frequency and mitigation options, CFD is suitable. Alkazar works with CFD only and does not perform wind tunnel tests. Let us define the right method for your project together. For a detailed comparison, see our guide Wind tunnel or CFD?
What is the difference between Lawson and NEN 8100?
Lawson criteria define thresholds and exceedance frequencies by activity category (sitting, standing, strolling, walking); NEN 8100 uses comfort classes from A to E and sets the class from the percentage of the year a wind speed threshold is exceeded. Numerical thresholds come from the relevant standard text; the project specification decides which one applies.

Related articles: Wind in passages under buildings: A straight corridor or a route with turns? · Where should courtyard openings be? How pedestrian-level wind changes with design

Solutions

Teklif Alın

Get a quote

Alkazar Technology
Privacy overview

No cookie other than the strictly necessary ones is placed on your device before you opt in. You can switch each category on or off separately and change your choice or withdraw your consent at any time through the "Cookie settings" icon in the corner of the page. Controller: Alkazar Mühendislik ve Danışmanlık Ltd. Şti.