Wind tunnel or CFD? Choosing the right method for your project

Short answer: A wind tunnel test and CFD are not rivals; which one is needed depends on the project’s regulation, specification and stage. If the regulation or the authority asks for a physical wind tunnel test, CFD does not take its place. If there is no such requirement and the aim is to assess facade pressures, pedestrian comfort or massing alternatives early, CFD is a suitable and practical method. The two are also used together. This guide neutrally collects the questions to ask when choosing a method.

Choosing a method in six questions

QuestionWind tunnel testCFD simulation
Does the regulation or specification ask for it explicitly?If so, it is required. For example, the Istanbul High-Rise Wind Regulation (Version V) asks for a tunnel test for non-standard structures.In that case it does not take its place; it produces site-specific results that can be read alongside the test.
What stage is the project at?Once the geometry is largely fixed and a physical model can be prepared.While massing and facade decisions are still open, alternatives can be compared digitally.
What do you want to learn?Pressures and wind effects measured on a scale model; also an established method for studying dynamic behaviour of very tall, slender structures.Local pressures across facade zones, velocity fields and comfort at pedestrian level, the effect of surrounding buildings.
Are there many geometry alternatives?Each new geometry needs a change to the physical model.Geometry changes can be tried digitally in the model.
Do you want to test mitigation?Measures such as wind breakers or canopies are tested by physically changing the model.Wind breaker, canopy and planting alternatives can be compared before construction.
How are the results read?Measurement-based; model scale and measurement set-up assumptions affect the result.Boundary conditions and the surrounding model affect the result; assumptions must be stated clearly in the report.

When is a physical wind tunnel test needed?

  • When the regulation, specification or authority asks for it explicitly. Example: the Istanbul High-Rise Wind Regulation asks for a tunnel test for non-standard structures. Confirm the scope of your project from the regulation text and the authority.
  • When the structure has a complex geometry or dynamic behaviour outside the scope of the standards and the design team wants measurement-based verification.
  • When a financier, insurer or consulting team makes a test report a condition.

When is CFD sufficient and more practical?

  • When the regulation or specification does not require a physical test.
  • When the aim is to compare massing and facade alternatives early.
  • When zone-by-zone pressure coefficients for cladding and the effect of surrounding buildings are needed; the EN 1991-1-4 calculation is made site-specific.
  • When pedestrian wind comfort is to be assessed against a criterion such as Lawson or NEN 8100.
  • When the effect of measures such as wind breakers, canopies or planting is to be compared.

In every case the authority and the specification have the last word on the accepted method.

How are the two used together?

On projects that need a tunnel test, CFD can be used before the test to narrow the geometry alternatives and identify critical zones, and after the test to help interpret why the two results differ. In this division of work Alkazar’s role is the CFD side; the facility that performs the test is selected separately.

Decision checklist

  1. Does the regulation and specification the project falls under ask for a physical test?
  2. Does the authority, financier or insurer require a particular method?
  3. Which output do you need: facade pressures, pedestrian comfort, a comparison of alternatives?
  4. What stage is the project at and how fixed is the geometry?
  5. How many alternatives do you want to compare?

What is Alkazar’s role?

Alkazar calculates facade wind loads and pedestrian-level wind comfort with CFD; for the scope see structure wind consultancy. More than 200 projects have been delivered since 2011.

Let us define the right method for your project together. Share your regulation, specification and project stage; get in touch.

Frequently asked questions

Can CFD be used instead of a wind tunnel test?
It depends. If the regulation or specification asks for a physical wind tunnel test, CFD does not take its place. If there is no such requirement and the questions are facade pressures, pedestrian comfort or comparing alternatives, CFD is a suitable method. The authority and the specification decide which method is accepted.
Is a wind tunnel test mandatory for a high-rise building?
It depends on the regulation the project falls under. For example, the Istanbul High-Rise Wind Regulation (Version V) asks for a physical wind tunnel test for non-standard structures and for independent control board approval for all high-rise designs within its scope. Elsewhere, or under a project-specific specification, the rules may differ; confirm the scope at the start from the regulation text and the authority.
Do wind tunnel and CFD results come out the same?
They are not expected to be identical. The two methods have different sources of uncertainty: model scale and measurement set-up in the tunnel, boundary conditions, the surrounding model and solver settings in CFD. The assumptions should therefore be stated clearly in the report and the results read against the same inputs.
Does Alkazar perform wind tunnel tests?
No. Alkazar does not operate a physical wind tunnel and does not perform tunnel tests; it works with CFD simulation only. This page neutrally collects the questions to ask when choosing the method that fits your project.
What outputs does CFD provide?
For facades: pressure coefficients and cladding zone maps for each wind direction. For pedestrian level: comfort maps by activity category and threshold exceedance frequency. For mitigation: comparative results for the alternatives.
How do I choose the right method?
Start with the regulation and specification, then the request of the authority, financier or insurer; then clarify the project stage and what you want to learn. Let us define the right method for your project together.

Solutions

Teklif Alın

Get a quote

Alkazar Technology
Privacy overview

No cookie other than the strictly necessary ones is placed on your device before you opt in. You can switch each category on or off separately and change your choice or withdraw your consent at any time through the "Cookie settings" icon in the corner of the page. Controller: Alkazar Mühendislik ve Danışmanlık Ltd. Şti.